Yup, the website broke. It's fixed now. Rest is technical babble.
One little bitty part of the domain transfer was missing. I've secured thegrim.org using DNSSEC. Part of moving to a new registrar and getting some renewal time - the keys used to sign the domain were refreshed, but never uploaded. This was made worse by the fact while NAME.COM (our DNS registrar) is great, their UI for DNSSEC is crap. As in, it's hidden - really well. Their support guys and gals did show me a screenshot as to where the hidden link was (you have to scroll down to the middle of a page with a wall-of-text and a tiny link). A few cut and pastes, and everything is working again.
So, if you have an ISP or use a DNS resolver that doesn't suck - you would have never been able to load thegrim.org, since, rightfully so, your software would think you are about to be haxx0red. I know that Comcast and Google's DNS is anal about DNSSEC - so if you use those, you got cut off.
The tl;dr:
We're back. Designing good UX is hard. Game on!